Categories
Right Angle

Why MLK Told Nichelle Nichols ‘You cannot’ Leave Star Trek

Nichelle Nichols’ passing this week at age 89 reminds us what made her Lt. Uhura essential, not just on the U.S.S. Enterprise, but for America. So profound was her impact, that when her self-professed biggest fan, Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., heard that she was leaving Star Trek, he told her “You cannot do that.” Plus, she was one half of the ‘the dangerous kiss.’ Join us for this tribute. 

Bill Whittle, Stephen Green and Scott Ott work for thousands of committed conservatives, who write their own blog, maintain a vigorous discussion on essential issues, and have a lot of fun. You’re not alone. You can join them them, and support this work, when you tap the big green button above.  

If you loved this episode of Right Angle, and want to say thanks, tap the big blue button to make a one-time or recurring donation with your PayPal or credit card.

See the whole Right Angle archive .

21 replies on “Why MLK Told Nichelle Nichols ‘You cannot’ Leave Star Trek”

It is very noteworthy that Star Trek was on during some of the worst times in recent history, times when the old ways of Jim Crow and segregation were being torn down. The openness and diversity shown on the Enterprise reflected the hope that was growing that we could get past all the anger, rioting and shrieking. There was the horrible rhetoric and brutality of Southern officials and police, and the burning and terror of the angry race riots in the North. As a young teenager, it was a very frightening time. Seeing all races, and even all beings, interact peacefully was inspirational. It was seen as what ‘normal’ should look like. The angry, vengeful rioting and evil racist tactics and rhetoric were the things that we had to get away from.

Trigger warning! We have a couple more centuries to go to eliminate “words are violence” and “silence is violence”. I look forward to Uhura’s time when words can never hurt us.

Great tribute to Lt. Uhura and the wonderful lady who portrayed her! Here’s a true Star Trek story: 24 yrs ago as my wife was carrying our first child, Star Trek was played every night in syndication and we watched it religiously. Months later, whenever the intro music came on TV, “Da da da, da da da da….Space, the Final Frontier…”, our infant daughter would instantly turn in the direction of the sound. Today, she is a beautiful young woman……and we still watch Star Trek together.

In the mid eighties I was an appliance repairman in Honolulu. One day I had a call at the home of a Mrs. Trible. In our conversation I asked her if she had been a Star Trek fan and she replied that her late husband had grown up with Gene Roddenberry and were close friends. The naming of those furry little creatures was a friendly jab at her husband.

It’s funny, her character was so well conceived, written and directed by the producers, writers and directors….and that same group gave us Yeoman Rand……can anyone in the BW universe explain Yeoman Rand and her role on the ship and not let it drift into the gutter?

There were ST:TOS related stories published in the late 80s and 90s. At one time I had a bunch of the paperbacks. I found them very enjoyable. One ( I think called Enterprise: The First Adventure but it may have been another) had a pretty compelling back story for Yeoman Rand. She was too young for Star Fleet but when she was found on a planet having been kidnapped with her younger siblings, she magically aged. In that story, Kirk is very frustrated with her incompetence. The officer who takes her under her wing to help her, Lt. Uhura.
Written by Vonda McIntyre.
I remember really enjoying those tales.
At one point I had more than 2 dozen of these paperbacks. I am going to need to search my old footlocker and shelves to see if I kept them or donated in one of the storage purges of the last 3 decades.

Another mention of Lt. Uhura’s race came in the first season episode “The Naked Time.” Sulu, as well as other crew members, is infected with something that causes them to act irrationality. Sulu is dashing through the ship with a sword and confronting everyone he meets as a musketeer would, when he sees Uhura. He pulls her to him to save her and calls her “fair maiden.” She replies, “Sorry, neither!”

Fantastic! I like to think that Nichelle came up with that line, herself.

I remember that episode, and to this day, for me, it was the creepy-est cringy-est Sulu moment in Star Trek history, seeing him running through the corridors with his shirt off. Cringe!

How much do you want to be it was one of Takei’s all-time favorites?

One of the things about modern Leftists that just ticks me off to no end is their insistence on finding, and especially creating, racism where there isn’t any.

Racism was a real issue where and when it existed. I grew up during the end of the era when there was real racism in the United States. But I didn’t grow up where there was any real racism. Because of that, I didn’t grow up with any ingrained historical prejudices against any other race and in a very real way that makes me an objective historical observer of the de-racialization of America.

Where I grew up, there were no black people at all. None. The only black people I saw during my early years were on television. This was during the era when television was broadcast as a radio signal and living in a rural area we were only able to receive two of the three major U.S. television networks so even my television based experience was limited.

My experiential young life was not contaminated by any negative views on any other race either positive or negative. Because of the religious beliefs of our family people were just people, all God’s Children.

When my sister and I were old enough my family participated in a program sponsored by our church that offered young, black inner city kids a two week stay in the rural area where I lived at that time. Mom signed us up for that program and that summer we had a guest who was a young black kid from an inner city environment.

His name was “Jimmy” and we had a blast playing with him for two weeks. He was amazed at how we lived, at the farm animals, at the quiet of the rural American countryside and all the things that were different from where he lived.

During that two weeks I do not recall ever thinking of him as anything but another kid to play with. The main difference between us that impressed me most was not his skin color but his home environment as he described it to us. I remember thinking “I’m so glad I don’t live where he does.” He slept in my room and as I recall he was a perfect guest. Polite, friendly, outgoing, he never snooped in anything and he certainly never stole anything. We were economic peers, his family was as poor as mine and the principle difference there was being as we lived on a farm we had much a much better food supply than he did at his home.

I know this latter fact because after he’d gone I asked my mom why Jimmy’s knees and elbows were so “knobby”. She explained what the condition known as ricketts was to me.

So not only was I not predisposed to any sort of racial bias, my very first experience with someone of another race than my Nordic heritage was a very positive one.

Fast forward to my enlistment in the Marine Corps. That was my next experience with black people. I expected them all to be like Jimmy, boy was I wrong. When I was in the Marines there were serious issues with racism. There was terrible friction between the races at that time. Camp Pendleton was locked down for two weeks for fear of race riots. If you think the BLM riots were bad imagine what Marines fighting Marines divided across racial lines would be like.

People were going to the brig all the time. The slightest excuse for a fight between a white guy and a black guy would flare up and everyone involved would be sent to the brig where they were all treated harshly. The Marine Corps was doing its best to contain and mitigate the problem but there was no doubt we had a serious problem back then.

What I learned from all of this and subsequent life experience is that the difference which causes problems isn’t a matter of race, it’s a matter of culture. Some, not all by a long shot but some of the black people I knew in the Marines were from a culture so alien to mine that they might as well be from another planet.

I have to emphasize that word “some” because one of the people I have most respected in my entire life was a black Marine Gunnery Sergeant named William (Billy) Tribble. It’s a hard name to forget even if I didn’t have good reason to remember it because I grew up as a serious Trekkie and there’s a Star Trek episode about little fur balls called “tribbles”. Later on in my Marine Corps life one of my best friends was a black guy from St. Louis named Donny Whitley. So yeah, some but by no means all …

I want everyone to know too that it wasn’t just the black Marines that were causing problems. There were white Marines who reacted to the unrest of black Marines by adopting a more-or-less pseudo-Nazi culture. There were swastikas and Nazi flags hanging in barracks room housing of some of the white guys. Those were taken down and hidden during barracks inspections and confiscated if they were found. This did the opposite of help the situation and that culture too is as alien to me as if from another planet. I despise Nazis and anything that smacks of Nazism.

This is why I’ll mock and deride you if you sound like a Nazi to me and there are absolutely people on the Right who sound like Nazis to my perception. There is always the very real danger of going too far on the Right, it’s as real a danger as going too far on the Left. I know this for a fact, I have seen it happen.

I’m telling you all of this so you’ll understand that I have experience with real racism, racism that posed a personal and immediate threat to my life and limb. I take this topic very, very seriously.

I have prejudices learned from and taught to me by life experience. My prejudices are cultural and justified by that experience. I have no racial bigotry at all but I certainly do have a cultural bias. I’ll give a person from my culture a chance to prove he’s an asshole and someone from another culture a chance to prove he’s not. I don’t care if people agree with me on this because this is what I have learned over a lifetime of experience and observation.

I’m white of Nordic ancestry. I’m as proud of what I am and who I am as anyone else of any other culture. I understand their pride in these things because I feel it too. I approve of that pride if it’s not destructive and anti-social. I do not approve of someone who takes it to extremes in any culture, we all have to live on this planet and I’ve spent a lifetime being a peacemaker. That doesn’t mean a lifetime of meekness and temerity, sometimes peacemakers have to stand against the un-peaceful with lethal force. You don’t want to be one of those people that men like me need to stand against and if you take things too far you are not on “my side” no matter what your politics are.

My dad was at San Diego twice (6 years total) first in boot camp then later a Drill Sargent at MCRD and in Oceanside twice (six years total) Camp Pendleton when he was a Staff Sargent then Gunnery Sargent.

He was called the n word many times up until he became a Gunnery Sargent when the troops seem to have quite a bit more respect for him. When he died there were a few hundred people at his funeral and that included over 100 guys from his troops with their families.

My siblings and I were called the n word during grade school in San Diego. But when we went back to Hawaii (2nd time) and then back to Oceanside early 70’s nobody called us that any more and we’re not even black. Back then, you were either black or white, there was no in-between.

I’d also add Professional, Competent and Brave. With Romulans and Klingons shooting at the ship, it seemed the only time her character got rattled or annoyed was when Star Fleet woudn’t answer her hailings. Her character was all Pro, and the actress was a pro for her ability to ‘sell it’.

i remember that episode- watching it in the living room with my parents. My dad saying “well done”: my mom being offended. Star Trek at the time really pushed the boundaries- but tastefully – really weird for a science fiction tv show….

Friday night in my high school years was dedicated to Star Trek. My husband-to-be and I never missed an episode if we could avoid it. I thought Lieutenant Uhura was beautiful, smart and everything I wanted to be as an adult. Sadly, I never was able to measure up to her show character but she sure was an excellent role model. Thanks, Bill, for a beautiful eulogy for a beautiful lady.

Thank you! I grew up on Star Trek, never missed an episode, and remember Lt. Uhura in exactly the way you and Steve recalled her: poised, confident and capable of anything required of her. Bill, you’re right – the Lincoln episode was an excellent “close” to this tribute to the lovely Nichelle Nichols.

What a beautiful ending to this episode and a timely challenge to Whoopi Goldberg and all the other race baiting celebrities of our day go back to the future.

Leave a Reply