Dear Mr. Whittle
I have been watching your show for many years now and I have been listening to you from the early days of PJ media. Your recent blog titled an American Army was viewed by me on Thursday, January 8, 2021. I must be honest with you Mr. Whittle It gives me great concern. I do not wish to waste my time or money barking up a tree so to speak. I have listened to you many times and dialectic of your current commentary is lacking. You seem to think that the only thing required to forge an “Army” in this country is discipline. Although I believe discipline is the foundational element of a new American movement going forward. Then to be joined again together as the once great United States of America. You certainly underestimate the challenges ahead and seem very naive. Let me say this. First, The America you seek to recover will never return. It is inexorably and forever gone. The Country has been thoroughly Deracinated. The only chance we have now is to divide and conquer. Just like the liberals did to this Country. Although I believe discipline is the foundational element of moving forward to the reunion of the once great United States of America. You certainly underestimate the challenges ahead. The only chance we have now is to divide and conquer and do our best to return those willing segments of this country back to their former glory. While you are correct, this will take a great deal discipline. There is literally no chance that this country will return the way you described it. I realize, there is a lot of missing detail in your analysis. However, I am certain that the path you describe in your quixotic rant will never come to fruition. For one thing, it begs the question how are you going to get your message out to the American people? Will you decide to go house to house and speak with every American? You certainly will never have such an opportunity to get your future messages out once the Biden juggernaut is at full steam. Neither YouTube nor social media will ever allow it. And I strongly suspect any books on the subject will soon be banned and your words will fall on deaf ears, as the miasma of totalitarianism falls across this country. Do you plan to get this message out to the people in person, or perhaps through megaphone, or maybe even by dispersing flyers? The chances that you will be arrested and label to heretic and enemy of the state is extremely high. Even if they are unable to stop you and the silence your voice, what makes you think you can change 170+ million people ‘s minds in the postmodern American left? Their power is now total and complete. They fully intend to use the Iron fist of government to crush any dissent. The liberal democratic mob and their postmodern friends are fully intending on flooding this country with illegal immigration and aliens of backwards countries; Then buy them off and placate them with handouts. You will never have the opportunity to educate them all quickly enough (besides many of them cannot read) in order to change the vote outcome. There is simply no chance even if you bring a legal suit against them in order to get your message heard. Keep in mind, they intend to stack the courts against you including the Supreme Court. Your voice will not be heard as you will fall into the sea of, just one of the deplorables. There are no individuals at this point, as individualism will be crushed. The states will be gone as a refuge as they intend to add to the number of states through statehood such as with Puerto Rico or the District of Columbia etc. It is my belief that there are a few border states of Mexico that will be included in the mix as well. Good luck with all that! I will not waste any more time or money on such risible segments like the one I saw tonight. I strongly suspect any books on the subject will soon be banned and your words will fall on deaf ears. I will not waste any more time or money on such an impossible enterprise. The only way forward is as you say.” Violence is sometimes the only thing that settles things.” Your shields will soon be taken away. They will ban ammunition and the accoutrements that support the second amendment. Be warned, people will always lash out when backed into a corner. The way forward would be to assemble this “Mob” and rally states like Texas to thwart the Federal Government at every turn. Just like California nullified immigration law. Texas should also consider issuing its own “commemorative” Crypto Currency and bar the IRS or FBI from entering Texas under threat of arrest. Then Texas and many other states can join together to pursue a Texit or British like negotiated exit. That is the way you win. That way you avoid violence as much as possible. Not by relying on some make believe future nonexistent “Next” President” Duly elected and has impeccable morals as well. They the Democrats will never ever allow this. Good lord man! you are from California. How is one party rule working there? Wake the Hell Up! When have you seen any of your dreams come to fruition in California? What makes you think it will ever happen across the entire nation. Beside you are right our enemies have control on all the information. Get real and stop moralizing stop, stop lecturing, and stop wasting our time’; or me and my money will go elsewhere. BTW. Your “diseased ego” is getting the best of you. You are not the only person who really understands. Get over yourself! And listen to others on this website. It would do you good to enlist these incredibly wise and intelligent patriots gathered here.
Don’t waste this chance.
Most sincerely
Mark Poullos
Fellow pilot, Inventor, entrepreneur and ego maniac.
13 replies on “Response to Bills “An American Army””
I agree. With all due respect to Bill, what he is envisioning is what we can build once A country exists for virtuous people. A present, we have lost control of all official offices and avenues. There is no other option left but to push through with as much force as necessary.
(Just a note here: All violence is force, but not all force is violence. We would all do well to remember that. That is why I use the word “force” specifically.)
Yes, we have a mob, an oddly disciplined mob when it comes to the violence and destruction you would expect from a mob. Not a single protester was armed, and I’m sure they would have preferred to be armed. Maybe it’s a good thing they were not. Not a single protester used their flag poles as weapons. Not a single protester attempted to beat up or kill another person. Any violence using fists was done is self-defense and those who actively aggressed were apparently not part of the protest, many such people were removed from the front.
I watched all of the events unfold in real-time on Jan. 6, and I have never seen a mob that delicately walked single-file between velvet ropes so as not to harm or disturb the artifacts in the building. Nor have I seen a mob specifically direct damage ONLY to those parts of the building that were clear obstacles. (I do not know the state of the various Congressmen’s offices. There may be some damage or confiscation that occurred there.) Nor have I seen a mob tear away and block a member that was causing purposeless damage. Nor have I also seen a mob so furious at the police for their oathbreaking, yet willing to STILL DEFEND THEM when a few people started trying to actively harm them. Further still, I have never heard of a mob that when asked politely to disperse and go home, disperse and go home within MINUTES of the order.
That, ladies and gentlemen, is discipline.
What we lack at present is someone to give orders and actionable objectives. That is what an army has–a general and officers. We don’t have that right now. What we have are angry, somewhat disciplined people who are lost and don’t know what to do with themselves. If they had direction: “Go here. Do this, this, and that. Come back.”, then we would have what Bill wants.
That said, what transpired Jan. 6 showed us all one thing: That we are fully capable of scaring our government officials if we wish to do so. That we could probably take our country back if we tried together.
Anyway, we can’t start electing citizens into offices until we have re-established trustworthy, honest systems of governance. We don’t have that right now. We’re surrounded by enemies who are more than happy to rip our beloved Constitution to shreds. These people have to be stopped first. THEN we can rebuild our Republic in the manner that it was always meant to be built.
Bill’s putting the cart before the horse.
Very well said sir.!
Sound very much like a strawman case. Bill never stated that discipline is the only thing needed, AAMOF even if we just take this single episode, from 15 minutes in he talks about the other, more important aspects. (I happen to have some disgreements on the first half, but there are very important points made and I can excuse the rest to the rhetorics needed to coin it down for the greenies.)
The base point is solid, the difference between army and mob IS discipline, and going with the mob and in general following the instincts as a jerk reaction is easy, but is a slippery slope. The energy and rage needs to be channeled to the right points.
And to the mass of arguments on how it is impossible to dismantle a totalitarian system — we have plenty of history to look at. Opposition did grow under oppression, censorship and all the massive efforts to root it out. Te word could spread well befor social media was invented or even a simple xerox was available. Actually if biden picks up the playbook of the red khmers the collapse will come even sooner. But it’s not likely, the baseline is the warm piss route. That is probably the longest to run, but USA is starting from a way more fragile situation than most people would realize. the biden combination of pushing the business out and pressing mass money will topple the ship faster than it happened last time in 2008. Yeah, you absolutely CAN run out of bread and circuses. It takes some effort, but the leftists are on top of it by default.
And I never stated he said discipline was the ONLY thing. I said” You seem to think that the only thing required to forge an “Army” in this country is discipline. Although I believe discipline is the foundational element of a new American movement going forward.”
I’m pretty confused. So despite he didn’t state it you conclude what he seems to think. No matter how you got there, that is the part I believe is not founded and is a strawman.
That is because he never emphasized the more salient elements required to “form an army”. He overly generalized the topic. As did I. life is never that simple. Nor is the solution Mr. Whittle stated. You can not teach orbital mechanics in a 30 minute diatribe. Nor can their be a complete response in one letter.
I think I’d disagree. My response was mentioned on an earlier post so here’s the link: https://billwhittlecom.wpenginepowered.com/what-the-hell-does-a-peaceful-resolution-look-like-exactly/#comment-29180
To be truthful I only gave it a “1” cuz of all the big words he used. LOL That post was…something. A very dark view of our future.
Anyway Sir, I have to admit I have been enjoying your content for a long time as a free grifter. I think the first video of yours I watched was when you portrayed the President giving a “State of the Union” address. It was awesome! Your “An American Amy” changed that status. Unlike Mark there, I was inspired by your words & vision.
I don’t see myself entering politics at this late stage in my life but I can give of my time and money to help win this fight. Again unlike Mark, I agree with you that we CAN win this thing.
This “war” won’t be fought like any previous one…our battlefield will be in the arena of the mind & soul…and for their freedom. I believe the American people are uniquely qualified for this battle because we have done it before!
In closing, I offer one of my fav quotes from Sir Winston Churchill: “You can always count on the Americans to do the right thing…after they have exhausted all the other possibilities.”
Lock & Load 🙂
Tim Personius
Big words?? where?
Am about to read your post, but if you could do us a favor and break the message in multiple paragraphs, a lot of people would very much appreciate it!
Sorry first post. I thought page space was limited ,ergo the very long paragraph . I cannot seam to find an edit button on the postings page.
Mouse over Members in the top menu, then over Read Blog and select My Blog Dashboard. There, you’ll find the edit button for your post. PM me if you need help. Thanks.
Thank you, For the Information, It is hard to do this stuff at work, I will edit it tonight when I get home. BTW, How is the furniture sales business after New Years?