I began typing this comment on the Mayor Pete Bill Whittle Now, and realized it was getting long enough that I should just make a blog post instead.
So, here is my position on homosexuality as a Christian. The Bible clearly condemns it as a sin, anyone who denies that hasn’t read their Bible or has formed their view of scripture based on their worldview, not the other way around, which is very dangerous. I’ve heard the arguments of “that part doesn’t count anymore” or “that can’t be taken literally” and have found them to be without substance. Both the Old and New Testaments condemn it; the beginning of Romans is a prime example.
That said, I cannot deny the evidence in front of my eyes which says some people are just born with homosexual attractions through no fault of their own. I do not believe these homosexual attractions are a sin, but acting on them is. A great comparison I like to make is anger. Some people, through no fault of their own, have a very short temper. That is not a sin, what is a sin is raging at those around you when you feel angry. No one would say “flying into a rage is not a sin, if it were, God would not make people who get angry easily.” Homosexuality is the same way, not everyone has those temptations, but it is still wrong to act on them. Everyone has their own unique sins that they struggle with. For some, that sin is homosexual behavior. Temptation is not a sin; even Jesus was tempted by Satan in the desert. Giving in to those temptations is a sin.
Homosexuality is not some top-tier unforgivable sin, it is one of many. Any person who has commited it should repent and ask God for forgiveness.
Another interesting thing to me as a Christian is that I know you can turn away from your homosexual nature and “go straight.” I have heard the testimonies of former homosexuals who came to Christ and then, through the healing power of Jesus, began living a perfectly heterosexual lifestyle. That tells me that homosexuality is not a permanent condition.
The aforementioned beginning section of Romans also says that when a person has thoroughly rejected God, God will give them over to the “lusts of their hearts” (Romans 1:24), and one of the sins that is listed after is homosexuality. This falls perfectly in line with the main message of the Bible: that human beings are sinful creatures by default. That they are born with a desire to do wrongful things. Some people are born with the desire to indulge their sexual nature with those of the same sex, and they should turn away from those sinful desires the same way we all should turn away from the desire to lie, cheat, steal, murder, and commit adultery.
In conclusion, according to the Bible, homosexuality is a sin. Certain people are born with homosexual desires according to their sinful human nature, and they should not indulge those temptations. Instead, they should turn away from them and ask Jesus for forgiveness and healing, so that he might give them a new heart and make a new creation of them in Christ.
“I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you; I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh.” – Ezekiel 36:26
And no, Christians do not hate homosexuals, only homosexuality. Hate the sin, love the sinner.
Let me know if you see any logical inconsistencies in my argument; it took me a while to form a cohesive point of view on homosexuality as a Christian, and it is possible that I am missing something. I look forward to answering any questions you may have on this subject.
9 replies on “The Biblical View of Homosexuality”
It’s always hazardous to start guessing at the authenticity of another’s religious views, because there’s no way to know for certain what is in their heart. But if someone where a Marxist, there is no way that they are a Christian. That wouldn’t stop the Marxist from using Christianity as a political weapon, though.
Let me recommend the excellent book Washed and Waiting: Reflections on Christian Faithfulness and Homosexuality by Wesley Hill, which is an exploration of the topic by a man who is a) a deeply committed, conservative Christian; b) sexually attracted to other men despite his continuing efforts to shed or alter that part of who he is. From the blurb on Amazon:
Another reason I believe homosexuallity is sinful is that I have never ever met or even seen an LGBT person who had a strong relation with Christ, which makes me think the two are at odds.
Your argument is a sound one.
However I try, though, I just can’t get my mind or heart around an all loving God who would condemn gays to Hell, just for having sex with someone who is the same gender. It’s only sex, it’s not like murder.
I do consider myself a Christian. I also choose to believe my God is all loving, not hateful and spiteful.
I never said all gays go to Hell, but remember, we all deserve to go to Hell for every one of our sins. God would be just in condemning someone as virtuous as Mother Teresa to Hell if not for Jesus’s sacrifice. Our salvation is wholly dependant on placing our faith in Christ, not on whether on not we did one of the really bad sins.
I do not believe in a hateful or spiteful God either; God is all loving and loves gay people just as much as anyone else, which is why Jesus died on the cross to forgive the sins of all mankind, including gays. God is both perfectly loving and perfectly just. His justice requires him to condemn sinners (which is all of us) to Hell, even for just having sex with a another man (or woman). His love caused him to offer up Jesus to step in front of that bullet meant for us and take the suffering of Hell upon himself so that we could be made right with God.
It seems to me that your problem was not with the premise that homosexuality is sinful, but that God could condemn “good people” (by human standards) to Hell. I hope this clears it up for you. Let me know if you have any other questions; I love talking theology.
But I don’t believe homosexuality is sinful. Why should it be a sin to love someone, simply because you are the same gender?
Why would God consider love a sin?
It isn’t love that’s sinful, it’s the romantic, sexual relationship. It is sinful because it goes against God’s original plan for marriage as one man, one woman, bonded together for life. Sin is rejecting God’s way in favor of our own, therefore homosexuality is a sin. God created men and women to be complementary, to round each other out and fulfill their own specialized roles. Homosexuality deprives people of that mutually beneficial relationship God had planned out for us in favor of something lesser. All sin is worse for us in the end than what God commands us to do.
Even if you do not understand God’s reasons, as we humans often don’t, you should trust that what he says is true and right. If you believe the Bible is the word of God, you should by extension believe homosexuality is sinful, even if you don’t understand why.
I could continue this conversation with you forever, but if you really want to understand why, you should go straight to the source. Read and study the Bible, and you will figure out the truth. I cannot stress that enough; if you want answers, the Bible is the best place to find them. Seek and ye shall find.
You said you think my argument is sound, yet you disagree with my conclusion. Where is it that your trail of logic diverges from mine, as I do not see how you could have a different view without disagreeing with some part of my post.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i38tLYOrt68&t=104s
Allie did a great video on it.
Is “love” not a sin when it involves heterosexual adultery or fornication?